VividSimon
Simply Perfect
Baseshment
I like movies that are aware of what they are selling... without [any] greater aspirations than to make people laugh and that's it.
Hadrina
The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful
Christmas-Reviewer
BEWARE OF FALSE REVIEWS & REVIEWERS. Some people only review one film. When it just one review you cant trust them no matter what their opinion may be. I have reviewed over 200 Holiday films. i have no agenda .The Shanty Where Santy Claus Lives is a Christmas-themed Merrie Melodies cartoon short, originally released in 1933. It makes use of a Great Depression setting of Christmas where Santa Claus is seeking shelter. The short takes place at a shantytown; hence the name "The Shanty Where Santy Claus Lives".Shot in black and white which adds to the tone of the overall animated short. Should be seen by everyone.
Edgar Allan Pooh
. . . Warner Bros.' warning division of Animated Shorts Seers (aka, their Looney Tunes prognosticators) were WITTING prophets of the upcoming Calamities, Catastrophes, Cataclysms, and Apocalypti facing We Americans of (the then) Far Future, or rather were receiving their Cassandra-like Revelations in a trance-like state of Mass Psychosis. When one examines THE SHANTY WHERE SANTA CLAUS LIVES for clues to answering this burning question, it's best to view SHANTY with its live-action prologue in the 8 minute, 53 second version. There we see a family of four (plus a mutt) gathered under the family Christmas Tree as Proud Pops screens SHANTY in lieu of any other Christmas presents. About six minutes later, the Yule Tree in Santa's SHANTY catches fire! It's hard to imagine a more ominous set of circumstances, especially in the midst of Holiday Season. No one in their right mind would INTENTIONALLY create such Dark Art. But think about it. The recent fire sale of America to our new American Czar the Red Commie KGB Monster Vlad "Mad Dog" Putin and his Puppet Rump occurred during the middle of a snowy Holiday Season, just as pictured by the Looney Tuners here. The orphan boy bamboozled into a Death Ride on Santa's Sleigh to a Siberian Gulag Fire Trap obviously symbolizes Czar Putin's deluded Red State Enablers, those folks guilty of conspiring to commit High Treason against America's Hallowed Constitution by activating its Racist "Electoral College" self-destruct clause for the fifth and final time (ALL FIVE crimes against Democracy perpetrated by what's now been co-opted as Putin's Deplorable Party; though America suffered mightily in the previous four instances of Racist Electoral College Meddling, this fifth outrage threatens to end us!). Certainly the weight of the evidence is that the Looney Tuners are America's Leading Oracles through Divine Intervention, rather than being conscious Futurists.
Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de)
"The Shanty Where Santy Claus Lives" is a 7-minute black-and-white sound cartoon from almost 85 years ago. It is a collaboration between Schlesinger Studios and Warner Bros and can be categorized under Merrie Melodies. The topic here is Christmas, not only because Santa makes an appearance, but because several Christmas tunes are included. The music is one of the film's strengths and same goes for the animation which is really clean and with more love to detail than most films from that era. Unfortunately, the story here is fairly uninteresting, almost non-existent, basically a collection of scenes with no real plot. This is also why I give this one a thumbs-down. Not even Harman and Ising can make this one work. I do not recommend it or really only during the holidays. Oh yeah, and it is not racist, do not be fooled by the politically correct plebs.
Mary-18
The animation is adorable and nicely done for how early this cartoon is. And the songs are catchy and fun. But there's just nothing very original or remarkable about "Shanty Where Santy Claus Lives." The plot-line is incredibly straight-forward and obvious, and even the toys are fairly predictable and behave relatively normally. A much better cartoon featuring Depression-era pathetic orphans who get a surprise visit from Santa is the 1936 "Christmas Comes But Once a Year."
