TrueJoshNight Truly Dreadful Film

TrueHello Fun premise, good actors, bad writing. This film seemed to have potential at the beginning but it quickly devolves into a trite action film. Ultimately it's very boring.

Jonah Abbott There's no way I can possibly love it entirely but I just think its ridiculously bad, but enjoyable at the same time.

Derrick Gibbons An old-fashioned movie made with new-fashioned finesse.

Joe Really surprised by Ken Loach! I've seen various of his films, and his films can be quite a cynical view on people at times despite the great ability to show humanity amongst it all as well.Here we have a more light-hearted movie as we see a handful of charming people who have been sentenced with community service to do, group together and find a cheeky way to get some money. Criminal it may be, but it all seems to not be (when it really is). Our main man really wants to change his life around now that he is a father and he is whom we concentrate our attention on.It's very funny, original, earthy and beautiful to watch. Some may have to concentrate to get to grips with the very strong Glasgow vernacular but it will be very much worth it.This is one I'd recommend to try. A nice simple gem of a movie. A really uplifting movie.

John Fraser In all my life, I never imagined a film's highlight could be a song by the Proclaimers of all people, a band I hate.This film is the most boring, clichéd, unlikeable film I have ever seen. To begin with, the characters are all unpleasant, without exception. Only the main protagonist is more than one dimensional, but is a violent thug who has had a Damascene conversion because he becomes a father and completely unsympathetic. The rest of the characters are little more than circus clowns and rather poor ones at that. There is plenty of violence, swearing and Irn bru, but little in the way of plot, engaging characters or narrative arc.I can't believe this film was made and has made me revise my opinion of Ken Loach. Absolutely awful!

daveyboy-1 'Never judge a book by it's cover' is a line used roughly halfway through this relatively benign recent effort from British directing stalwart Ken Loach. This is a maxim to keep in mind if approaching Angel's Share with the poster's main advertising soundbite 'Scotland's answer to The Full Monty' as a trusted precursor. Like wine or whisky tasting itself, much of a film's effect is to do with the aftertaste, and it is only in the closing third of the film that the aforementioned tagline could bolster a challenge to be relevant at all, as Angel's Share, upon full viewing, provides an awkward mixture of traditional 'Loachian' working-class realism with lovable-rogue, schadenfreude comedy.There is much to like and take away from Angel's Share, including great dialogue, brilliant comedy and memorable characters. The problem is that these elements span what feels like two films fighting each other to exist in one, with neither sitting comfortably together or allowing the viewer to solidify a perspective to settle on in terms of their relation to the main characters. It could certainly be argued that this should precisely be the case for the parts of the film which reflect how ambiguously and inconsistently characters in real life can behave, but when Loach suddenly wants to do good on that tagline, all that comes before betrays the impish, happy-go-lucky final third that is well written yet foreboded by scenes not dissimilar from the violence in films like Sweet Sixteen. Imagine some of the generic, heart-warming, feel-good comedy scenes in The Full Monty interspersed with gang beatings and attempted grievous bodily harm and you can imagine the failed dichotomy displayed during Angel's Share.This disharmony in tone, however, is pleasingly the only main fault of the film, which can certainly be included as another of Loach's great accomplishments. Taken on a scene-by-scene basis, both the characters and the actors portraying them are addictively watchable, as they blunder and plunder as worst and best they can in the context of their worlds. The theme, born from the meaning of the title itself, is subtly explored and comes wonderfully full circle as that aftertaste at the end is about to kick in. There is honest drama amongst the frivolous escapading, much coming via the standout performance by John Henshaw as the poor guy charged with overseeing the group's community service tasks. It also includes the only known example to me of the use of '(I'm Gonna Be)' 500 Miles by The Proclaimers where the lyrics actually fit the context of the story as opposed to simply occupying a clip because they are Scottish (other stereotypes do exist, however, such as Irn Bru and kilt wearing, though these also exist in logical situations even if they may grate some at the front end).Loach's style is never compromised as regards to the way the film is shot, even if it strays in tone come the end of the story. Glasgow is shown rather than shown off, with barely an establishing shot in sight, helping to bring the viewer down to the level at which the characters themselves exist at - drab interiors, hostile alleyways, rundown tenement areas, etc. It is when the group set off on their daring 'heist' that the beautiful shots of the Highlands offer a sensible contrast as a visual metaphor - the job at hand providing faint hope of starting afresh (even though it is still a crime they are intending to commit). An awful, almost ten-minute tour of the whiskey distillery makes you feel like you've wandered into the filming of a tour itself rather than still watching a film, but is subsequently saved by the attempted pilfering of the 'Holy Grail' of whiskies - perfectly paced and ramped up with tension. In fact the crux of the story is so well crafted it almost makes you forget how little reason you should have to root for the success of the group's plan in the first place. Intentionally ambiguous yet jarringly inconsistent, Angel's Share succeeds in delivering an entertaining and memorable mixture of comedy and drama. Just ignore that tagline, and watch out for the aftertaste . . .

justineadrien My main conclusion after watching The Angels' Share is that Ken Loach is as good to make a comedy as a drama. The Angels' Share is a sweet comedy with social realism(as usual in Ken Loach movie) which shows how difficult it is to change your life but difficult doesn't mean impossible ! And when Robbie goes to see his newborn I just thought that even on the worst day, there is a possibility for joy ... I found this movie funny, pleasant and poignant in the same time. The acting is great even if there are no really known actors besides John Henshaw who already played in a Ken Loach movie ("Looking for Eric"). So I would recommend this movie to everyone.