Lumsdal Good , But It Is Overrated By Some

TaryBiggBall It was OK. I don't see why everyone loves it so much. It wasn't very smart or deep or well-directed.

Fatma Suarez The movie's neither hopeful in contrived ways, nor hopeless in different contrived ways. Somehow it manages to be wonderful

Lela The tone of this movie is interesting -- the stakes are both dramatic and high, but it's balanced with a lot of fun, tongue and cheek dialogue.

Edgar Allan Pooh . . . was the main villain of MIRACLE ON 34th STREET, John Nesbitt's "Passing Parade" assures Americans that the plant psychologist will find a place for Every Man, and that Every Man will be put in his place, as the country gears up for WWII. The aptitude tests of these Pioneer Days in Psychology were no grueling 500-question personality inquisitions accompanied by fill-in-the-bubble machine-scored answer sheets. Instead, job candidates were asked to flip over 200 casino chips as accurately and quickly as they could. Then they had to perform tasks while being flustered. Next they got to build a bridge to an island in the shrink's office wading pool. After that they tried to draw circles free hand that were round enough to keep dogs from barking. Finally, they were given long poles to see if they could knock a banana from a bunch tied up near a high ceiling quicker than a monkey could. If there were still a place to get "tested" in such a fashion today, I'd be willing to pay the price of admission. OF PUPS AND PUZZLES makes this brave new world of corporate psychology look like loads of fun!

Mich S Interesting short documentary about the emergence of personnel tests for screening job applicants when there was the need for massive hiring and selection for a wide variety of jobs in factories to support WWII. The film states that tests for humans were derived from psychological research with animals. An experiment showed dogs who were trained to recognize abstract symbols as precursors for food rewards, and then had varying 'emotional' reactions when they could not decipher the meaning of a novel stimulus. (thus film title, Pups and Puzzles) The film showed that if a novel stimulus is presented while humans take a personnel test, then the psychologist can determine the individual's temperament. The psychologist fired a pistol over the heads of job applicants to see if they could recover quickly from being startled and successfully conclude their math test. Certainly this method of determining 'adaptability', would not be acceptable in today's time either for research or employment testing! Personnel testing has come a long way since then! The film is crafted to be amusing for all audiences, but it is really most amusing in its historical perspective. It will be of particular interest to research psychologists and industrial/ organizational personnel specialists.

Michael_Elliott Of Pups and Puzzles (1941) *** (out of 4)Oscar-winning Passing Parade short with John Nesbitt talking about various ways employers hire people in today's world. The short talks about how foremen use to hire just by looking at the physical nature of a person but today psychological profiles are used to determine what type of jobs would best suit a person. Here is where we see various tests, which are also tried on dogs and a chimp. This is a fairly entertaining short not because of how smart it is but instead just because it's rather cute and charming. The trick in teaching the three puppies was a rather cute one and the monkey trying to reach his bananas was very funny. Seeing some of the men trying to do their tricks also provided a couple laughs in this winning short.

John Hedtke We take employee testing and psychological profiles for granted these days, but for the audiences of 60 years ago who hired people by pointing, this was informative. Information is boiled down a bit beyond any reasonable application, but what the heck--it's a short film. And it's particularly interesting to see the psychologist doing the testing get the applicants to fill out a form and then stands behind them and fires six shots in the air from a revolver to see how they react. Now that's two-fisted personnel management! :)The film has that "industrial giant of the American century" feel to it like many similar films, but it's interesting to see for the way in which information is presented.