Matialth
Good concept, poorly executed.
Listonixio
Fresh and Exciting
Huievest
Instead, you get a movie that's enjoyable enough, but leaves you feeling like it could have been much, much more.
Mandeep Tyson
The acting in this movie is really good.
Matthew_Capitano
To the producers of this show: THERE IS ONLY ONE CAPTAIN KIRK (William Shatner). We don't want to see some ugly effeminate dude with a high-pitched voice trying to stand in for the great Bill Shatner. THERE IS ONLY ONE MR. SPOCK (Leonard Nimoy). We don't want to see some guy with a goofy haircut and the wrong complexion who looks like he's 11-years old doing a bad job of trying to be Spock.Same notation for all the other characters. And therein lies the problem: the producers should have used all new characters (example: Captain Smith, Science Officer Jones, etc.), and they should be on a different ship (example: U.S.S. Independence).The idea to 'continue' the series with a Starfleet ship, the same sets, the same ship sounds, the same uniforms (especially the chicks in those mini-skirts), this was an exciting idea. But to get other actors to play such beloved characters from the original series was a death sentence for the show.An example of my theory is the new character of Elise McKenna (Michele Specht). She is believable and beautiful. This was a promising show idea, but when the producers came to the question of either making the crew the same characters from the original series - or - making the crew a different one, they made the wrong choice.Opportunity missed. Too bad.
gman007-1
I simply could not believe that someone had finally gotten it right. I've waded thru a lot only to emerge after decades of wannabe shows and movies landing on this incredible extension of what was truly original. My deepest thanks.
marino-simic
The series is a nice attempt however the protagonists are not well skilled actors and the story writers are doing noobish canon and fact mistakes.Claims such as "this ship has been improved to be able to do warp 15 at least" is total rubbish since we know that:"By the 24th century, infinite velocity was designated as warp factor ten. It was considered to be unattainable by conventional means."
amicakovic
Of course Im used to the TOS Characters and Actors, so I was very sceptical about this series. Still as the Trekki that I am of course I gave it a try. And the series is great. Already with the second episode it caught me fully, it delivers the same sense and feeling as the Orig. Series(n thats what is intended) n sticks to the philosophical and idological aspects of "Human" Nature as I guess was intended by mr. roddenberry.It didn't only braught back childhood memories, but also made me reminisince and rethink my actions and since I first watched the series as a youngster. (i know that thats totally personal and has nothing to do with the series, except using as a testemony to the quality it has.)Im impressed and delighted, and i hope they keep up the good work."Excuse my bad English, enjoy the show"
